Table of Contents

Sandia to Launch Gen-3 Particle-Based CSP Demonstration This Fall: A New Era for Solar Thermal Energy

Sandia to Launch Gen-3 Particle-Based CSP Demonstration This Fall

In a significant leap forward for renewable energy technology, Sandia National Laboratories is set to launch its Generation 3 (Gen-3) particle-based Concentrated Solar Power (CSP) demonstration this fall. This project represents a pivotal moment in the evolution of solar thermal energy, aiming to overcome the limitations of previous CSP systems and pave the way for more efficient, cost-effective, and scalable solar power solutions. Backed by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), this initiative is the culmination of years of research and development, and it could redefine the future of utility-scale solar power.

Background: The Evolution of Tower-Type CSP in the U.S.

Early CSP Projects and Their Limitations

The United States has been a pioneer in the development of tower-type CSP systems. The first two utility-scale tower CSP plants—Crescent Dunes in Nevada and Ivanpah in California—were completed in the early 2010s. These projects demonstrated the potential of CSP to deliver dispatchable solar energy, thanks to their ability to store thermal energy and generate electricity even when the sun isn’t shining.

However, these early systems faced several challenges:

High Costs: The capital expenditure for building and maintaining these plants was significantly higher than for photovoltaic (PV) systems.
Thermal Efficiency: The use of molten salt as a heat transfer fluid limited the operating temperature to around 565°C, capping the thermal-to-electric conversion efficiency.
Operational Issues: Molten salt systems are prone to freezing and corrosion, leading to maintenance challenges and operational downtime.

The DOE’s Gen-3 CSP Funding Competition

Recognizing the need for innovation, the DOE launched a funding competition in 2018 to determine the most promising technology for the next generation of tower CSP systems. The goal was to identify a heat transfer medium that could operate at higher temperatures—up to 800°C or more—thereby increasing efficiency and reducing costs.

Three competing technologies were evaluated:

Molten salt (improved version)
Gas-based systems
Particle-based systems

After rigorous testing and evaluation, the DOE selected Sandia’s particle-based system as the most promising candidate for Gen-3 CSP development.

What is Particle-Based CSP?

How It Works

Unlike traditional CSP systems that use molten salt or gas to transfer heat, particle-based CSP uses solid particles—typically ceramic or sand-like materials—as the heat transfer and storage medium. These particles are heated directly by concentrated sunlight in a solar receiver located at the top of a tower.

The process involves the following steps:

Heliostats (mirrors) focus sunlight onto a receiver at the top of a tower.
Particles flow through the receiver and are heated to temperatures exceeding 800°C.
The hot particles are stored in insulated containers for later use.
When electricity is needed, the thermal energy from the particles is used to generate steam, which drives a turbine connected to a generator.

Advantages Over Previous Systems

Higher Operating Temperatures: Particle systems can reach temperatures above 800°C, significantly improving thermal efficiency.
Lower Cost: The materials used are inexpensive and abundant, reducing overall system costs.
Improved Durability: Solid particles are less prone to corrosion and freezing compared to molten salts.
Scalability: The modular nature of the system allows for easier scaling to meet different energy demands.

Sandia’s Gen-3 Particle-Based CSP Demonstration

Project Overview

Sandia National Laboratories, located in Albuquerque, New Mexico, has been at the forefront of particle-based CSP research for over a decade. The upcoming Gen-3 demonstration is the culmination of this work and will be hosted at the National Solar Thermal Test Facility (NSTTF).

The demonstration will feature a 1 MWth (megawatt thermal) system designed to validate the performance, reliability, and cost-effectiveness of particle-based CSP technology. Key components include:

A high-flux solar particle receiver capable of heating particles to over 800°C
A particle storage system with thermal insulation to minimize heat loss
A heat exchanger to transfer thermal energy from particles to a working fluid
Instrumentation for real-time monitoring and data collection

Goals and Objectives

The primary objectives of the Gen-3 demonstration are:

To validate the technical feasibility of particle-based CSP at high temperatures
To assess the long-term durability and performance of system components
To collect operational data for future scale-up and commercialization
To demonstrate cost reductions that make CSP competitive with other renewable technologies

Case Studies and Global Context

International Interest in High-Temperature CSP

While Sandia’s project is a U.S.-based initiative, interest in high-temperature CSP is growing globally. Countries like China, Spain, and Australia are investing in advanced CSP technologies to complement their renewable energy portfolios.

For example, China’s SUPCON Delingha 50 MW tower CSP plant has been exploring higher-temperature molten salt systems, while Australia’s Vast Solar is developing modular tower CSP systems with thermal storage. These international efforts underscore the global relevance of Sandia’s Gen-3 demonstration.

Lessons from Crescent Dunes and Ivanpah

The Crescent Dunes project, despite its innovative use of molten salt storage, faced operational setbacks due to salt freezing and maintenance issues. Ivanpah, which uses a gas-based system, struggled with cost overruns and lower-than-expected performance. These experiences highlight the need for more robust and efficient technologies—needs that Sandia’s particle-based system aims to address.

Economic and Environmental Implications

Cost Competitiveness

One of the DOE’s primary goals for Gen-3 CSP is to achieve a levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of $0.05/kWh. Particle-based systems, with their higher efficiency and lower material costs, are well-positioned to meet this target. If successful, this would